HAMLETS MILL PDF
Hamlet's Mill. An essay on myth and the frame of time. GIORGIO de SANTILLANA . Professor of the History and Philosophy of Science M.l.T. and. HERTHA von. An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge and. Its Transmission Through Myth. Hamlet's Mill. by Giorgio de Santillana and Hertha von Dechend. Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge and Its Transmission .. Print/export. Create a book · Download as PDF · Printable version.
|Language:||English, Spanish, Arabic|
|Genre:||Academic & Education|
|ePub File Size:||MB|
|PDF File Size:||MB|
|Distribution:||Free* [*Regsitration Required]|
Best Download [Giorgio De Santillana] ✓ Hamlet's Mill || [Mystery Book] PDF ä, Ever since the Greeks coined the language we commonly use for scientific. download Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge And Its Transmission Through Myth on sppn.info ✓ FREE SHIPPING on qualified. Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time. byDe Santillana, Giorgio, For print-disabled users. Borrow this book to access EPUB and PDF files.
I give my reasons to believe that the essay does not prove that Hamlet's Mill has been "debunked" at all. On the contrary, I would argue that the examples the author brings out to "debunk" Hamlet's Mill when he finally gets around to bringing them out demonstrate his lack of understanding of their thesis and argument.
Admittedly, Hamlet's Mill is a dense and somewhat convoluted read. It takes a lot of time to piece through it and tease out the direction of the arguments.
Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time
However, that in and of itself does not invalidate the arguments. This author apparently has not taken the time to grasp the argument completely.
It is somewhat ironic that Gary David Thompson accuses the authors he is especially critical of von Dechend of being disorganized, saying: "The contents of the book are poorly organised and presented.
The book contains an immense amount of loosely related information but there is no persuasive evidence presented for the connections being made.
Thompson's essay can also be accurately described as containing an "immense amount of loosely related information.
Thompson included it at all or why the reader would be interested in learning it. I am not sure why the room number of lectures from the s or the times that seminars met is important to his argument at all, nor why I should want to know which airport Dr.
In fact, the first part of Mr. Thompson's criticism of the authors of Hamlet's Mill recalls the ad campaign describing an imaginary syndrome called "search overload," in which jumbles of information without any context would be recited by a character in a trance-like state, to humorous effect see this video for an example -- the first half of the article suffers from the same problem.
Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time
I can only believe that Mr. Thompson included all of that very detailed information about the personalities and lives of de Santillana and von Dechend as a giant ad hominem attack that is supposed to discredit them and dissuade anyone from reading their work.
I do not believe that is a good way to determine whether or not someone's analysis has merit -- I believe it is much more important to examine the person's analysis itself and make a judgment that way. I believe it is quite unfair to attack the author, as if there are any human authors about whom you cannot find plenty to criticize. I personally do not care if de Santillana and von Dechend received their insights directly from aliens -- if their insights and analysis appears to be supported by close examination of the myths or astronomical phenomena that they describe, then it may be worthwhile in advancing human knowledge in fact, even if only some of their insights turn out to be borne out by independent analysis, then it can be said to be of value.
I have personally examined their text very carefully and I can attest to the fact that their insights are absolutely borne out by close examination of the contents of myths from the familiar episodes of Homer to the less-familiar mythology of Polynesia some of the examples I use in my book come from myths reported by independent researchers of the cultures of the Pacific, many of them published before Hamlet's Mill was published.
Of course I do not agree with every sentiment espoused by de Santillana and von Dechend, nor with every aspect of their own personal belief systems or with everything they did during their lifetimes.
But to mock them for things they did or believed during the decades that they lived which were very different times in the world of academia than those of today or of the past couple decades is both uncharitable and unhelpful.
Which implies that those monks had access to original Aryan texts Its worth noting, that when the Maitreyasamiti texts were found, they were immediately readable because they were written in a classic Brahmi Sanskrit font. Despite being found in what is now NW China. They found a false wall, and behind it a cache of thousands of scrolls, the above is but one.
And that's just one temple. We have ghost towns out west that were abandoned years ago. They have ghost towns, like Niya, that were abandoned over years ago.
The extensive notes and indices provided should help in securing this work its well-deserved place on the reference shelf of the historian of philosophy, allowing him to replace the too often heard banalities about the "passage of philosophy into Europe" with trenchant specifics based upon primary research.
An Essay on Myth and the Frame o[ Time. By Giorgio de Santillana and Hertha yon Dechend.
Gambit Press, Their thesis is that certain archaic societies in the Far East, Middle East and South America possessed a profound knowledge of the kinematics, if not the dynamics, of astronomy, and that this knowledge, entailing "prodigious feats of concentration and computing," was encoded in their respective mythologies.
This archaic astronomical monomyth, diffused from China to Peru, no longer exists in its pristine integrity but has to be painfully teased out of the flotsam and jetsam that surfaces sporadically in chronicles, epics and latter-day literary myths, and it is to this task that the authors address themselves.
The result is unconvincing. Erudite references are heaped together with too little attention to designing a credible argument; tenuous associations are passed off as sensational and indubitable proofs: Though Jung might well have sponsored this enterprise, the authors sneer at both brands of depth psychology.The full hardcover title is Hamlet's Mill: On the contrary, I would argue that the examples the author brings out to "debunk" Hamlet's Mill when he finally gets around to bringing them out demonstrate his lack of understanding of their thesis and argument.
Mythology treats this event using metaphors that could be understood in pre-history times. The discussion page may contain suggestions.
The theme of the chosen imagery of the Erra-Epic is believed to refer to a disastrous military event that occurred to the city of Babylon in the "dark age" at the beginning of the first millennium BCE. On page , a rabbinical and a Pawnee tradition show "mistakable" identity. This archaic astronomical monomyth, diffused from China to Peru, no longer exists in its pristine integrity but has to be painfully teased out of the flotsam and jetsam that surfaces sporadically in chronicles, epics and latter-day literary myths, and it is to this task that the authors address themselves.